Introduction

Does your cat turn their nose up at dinner more often than not? If you've ever opened can after can in search of something they'll actually eat, you're not alone. The Earthborn Holistic Monterey Medley Skipjack Tuna and Grilled Mackerel Dinner promises to change that story. Crafted with wild-caught fish, a grain- and gluten-free recipe, and a nutrient-rich profile, this wet cat food offers an appealing balance of flavor, texture, and quality. For cat parents seeking a premium seafood entrée that satisfies even the most finicky eaters, this formula deserves a close look.

Quick Verdict

The Earthborn Holistic Monterey Medley delivers excellent palatability and solid nutrition for cats who love fish. Made with wild-caught skipjack tuna and grilled mackerel, it offers high-quality proteins while remaining free from grains and artificial fillers. The food's chunky, flaked texture mimics authentic seafood, which many cats prefer over dense pâtés.

That said, the protein level (minimum 12%) is moderate rather than extreme, and the 3-ounce can size can make it pricier per ounce compared to larger formats. Still, for most cats and owners, this product strikes an outstanding balance between taste, health, and quality sourcing—ideal as a daily meal or a tasty topper to dry kibble.

Features

Here's what sets the Monterey Medley apart:

• Premium fish proteins – Made from wild-caught skipjack tuna and grilled mackerel, flaked straight from the bone for a fresh texture and natural flavor.

• Grain- and gluten-free formula – Suitable for cats with grain sensitivities or allergies, using clean protein sources instead of fillers.

• Dolphin-safe and responsibly sourced – The seafood used is dolphin-safe, reflecting the brand's sustainability commitment.

• Added vitamins and minerals – Potatoes provide beta-carotene and vitamins for immune health, while taurine supports vision and heart function.

• Skin and coat nourishment – Includes sunflower oil and omega fatty acids to help maintain glossy, healthy fur.

• For all life stages – Formulated to meet AAFCO nutrient profiles for kittens, adults, and seniors.

• Convenient packaging – Sold as a 24-pack of 3-ounce cans, ideal for freshness and portion control in smaller households.

These features make Monterey Medley a strong choice for cats that thrive on a high-moisture, fish-based diet with responsibly sourced ingredients.

Performance

Palatability & Cat Acceptance

The biggest compliment a cat food can receive? An empty bowl. In this department, Monterey Medley earns glowing feedback. Cats drawn to intense fish aromas typically adore this food. Its shredded texture—flaked pieces of tuna and mackerel swimming in a light broth—offers an authentic seafood experience. Many owners report that even previously picky eaters start finishing their meals once this food is introduced.

The natural scent and visible chunks of fish give it a homemade feel, appealing to cats who dislike heavily processed foods or pâtés. The portion size also helps encourage freshness; one can per meal ensures that food is served moist and aromatic every time.

Nutritional Value & Digestibility

This recipe focuses on high-quality animal protein sources—essential for obligate carnivores like cats. The guaranteed analysis typically includes:

• Crude protein: min 12%

• Crude fat: min 2%

• Crude Fiber: max 1.5%

• Moisture: max 82%

While the protein percentage is slightly lower than some ultra-premium formulas, the quality of the protein stands out. Wild-caught fish provides a complete amino acid profile, and the high moisture content supports hydration—crucial for urinary tract and kidney health.

Because it's grain- and gluten-free, cats with food sensitivities or mild allergies often tolerate this recipe well. Added vitamins, minerals, and taurine make it nutritionally complete for daily feeding, though some owners also mix it with dry food for variety.

Texture, Aroma & Feeding Experience

The Monterey Medley has a flaked, meaty consistency—distinctly different from paste-style cat foods. It's easy to portion, smells like real fish, and looks like shredded tuna with visible mackerel flakes in light gravy. Cats who enjoy texture and chewing find it more engaging, and the broth helps boost water intake.

For the human side of the experience, the pull-tab cans are easy to open, and the portion size eliminates leftovers. Each 3-ounce can generally serves one meal for an average-sized cat. For households with multiple cats, it's simple to serve several cans without worrying about waste or spoilage.

Skin, Coat & Overall Health Benefits

Owners frequently note shinier coats and improved skin health after consistent feeding. The natural omega fatty acids in tuna, mackerel, and sunflower oil support coat gloss and reduce dryness or dandruff. Taurine promotes heart and eye function, while the formula's moisture content can help cats prone to dehydration or urinary crystals.

Energy levels also tend to remain stable. Since the food is lighter in fat (2%), it's a good choice for maintaining lean muscle without excessive calorie intake—especially beneficial for indoor cats or those needing weight control.

Long-Term Reliability

Earthborn Holistic maintains a strong reputation for consistent manufacturing quality. The Monterey Medley line has not been associated with major recalls and is produced under strict quality controls. Cats seem to tolerate it well over time without digestive issues, as long as transitions are made gradually.

For long-term feeding, it offers a clean, balanced nutritional profile with real-food appeal—ideal as a core diet or a flavor rotation within a mixed feeding plan.

Potential Drawbacks

A few small considerations:

• The protein level (12%) is moderate rather than high, so highly active or large-breed cats might benefit from rotating with a higher-protein formula.

• The 3-oz can format, while convenient, can add up in cost compared to larger 5.5-oz cans.

• Contains potatoes and guar gum as thickeners—harmless to most cats but worth noting for those with sensitive stomachs.

• Transitioning too quickly may cause mild digestive upset, as with any diet change.

Overall, these are minor trade-offs for the quality and palatability delivered.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Wild-caught skipjack tuna and grilled mackerel for premium protein.

• Grain- and gluten-free—ideal for sensitive cats.

• Dolphin-safe and sustainably sourced ingredients.

• Rich in omega fatty acids for healthy skin and shiny coat.

• Suitable for kittens, adults, and seniors.

• Flaked texture closely mimics real fish.

• Convenient 3-oz cans reduce food waste and help maintain freshness.

Cons

• The protein level (12%) is moderate compared to some competitors'.

• Slightly higher cost per ounce due to small can size.

• Contains potatoes and guar gum, which some ultra-sensitive cats may not tolerate.

• Strong fish aroma may not appeal to all owners (though cats love it).

Comparison

Versus Weruva Mackerel in Broth

Weruva's fish-based recipes are known for exceptionally high protein (around 14–15%) and ultra-simple ingredient lists—typically fish, water, and minimal additives. Compared to Earthborn Holistic, Weruva offers slightly denser nutrition but often at a higher price. The texture of Weruva's food is softer and brothier, while Monterey Medley delivers chunkier flakes that more closely resemble authentic seafood. If your cat enjoys chewing or visible texture, Monterey Medley is the winner; if ultra-high protein and minimal ingredients matter most, Weruva has the edge.

Versus Tiki Cat Wild Salmon & Whitefish

Tiki Cat's formulas are often considered "boutique gourmet" in the wet-food market—grain-free, high-protein, and visually appealing. The salmon-and-whitefish recipe competes closely in flavor and quality but comes in at a premium cost. Tiki Cat's pâté texture differs significantly from the flaked Monterey Medley, which many cats find more satisfying. Monterey Medley's advantage lies in its balanced nutrient profile, more affordable case pricing, and appealing real-fish chunks.

In short:

• Monterey Medley = Balanced nutrition, texture variety, responsible sourcing, moderate price.

• Weruva = Higher protein, broth-heavy texture, higher cost.

• Tiki Cat = Gourmet appeal, very high protein, most expensive option.

Monterey Medley fits comfortably between the two—premium yet practical.

Buying Guide

Before adding any wet cat food to your shopping cart, keep these considerations in mind:

1. Check the protein quality, not just quantity. Cats thrive on animal-based protein. Monterey Medley offers wild-caught fish, ensuring digestible, high-value amino acids, even with a moderate percentage.

2. Consider life stage needs. This food meets AAFCO nutrient profiles for kittens and adults, but portion sizes differ. Kittens and active cats may need more frequent meals.

3. Texture preferences matter. Some cats prefer pâtés; others prefer shredded or flaked food. The Monterey Medley's flaky chunks are ideal for cats who enjoy texture.

4. Watch for allergies and sensitivities. Grain-free formulas like this are great for cats with wheat or corn allergies, but always review for secondary ingredients such as potatoes or gums.

5. Plan portion control. A 3-oz can suits a single meal for an average 8- to 10-lb cat. For multi-cat homes, calculate daily consumption to gauge cost effectiveness.

6. Gradual transition is key. When switching foods, gradually increase the amount of the new food in your cat's diet over 5–7 days to minimize digestive upset.

7. Storage and freshness. Keep unopened cans in a cool, dry place. Once opened, refrigerate leftovers immediately and use within 24 hours.

8. Budget accordingly. While smaller cans cost more per ounce, they minimize waste and guarantee freshness—a fair trade-off for single-cat homes.

By factoring in your cat's life stage, appetite, and dietary preferences, you can decide whether Monterey Medley is the best fit—or one of several options in rotation.

Final Verdict

The Earthborn Holistic Monterey Medley Skipjack Tuna & Grilled Mackerel Dinner offers an outstanding balance of quality, taste, and nutrition. With real, wild-caught fish and a grain-free formulation, it caters perfectly to cats that crave seafood and benefit from clean, wholesome ingredients. The texture encourages healthy hydration and enjoyment at mealtime, while the added oils and nutrients support a lustrous coat and steady energy.

Although it isn't the highest-protein or cheapest wet food on the market, its overall formula integrity, palatability, and safety standards make it a trustworthy choice. For cat owners seeking dependable, flavorful, and responsibly sourced wet food, Monterey Medley earns a strong recommendation.

FAQs

Q1: Is Earthborn Holistic Monterey Medley suitable for kittens?
Yes. It meets AAFCO nutrient standards for all life stages, meaning it's nutritionally complete for both kittens and adult cats.

Q2: Is this food safe for cats with grain allergies?
Absolutely. The formula is 100% grain- and gluten-free, making it suitable for cats with sensitivities to wheat, corn, or soy.

Q3: How much should I feed my cat?
For adult cats, feed approximately one to two 3-oz cans per 4.5 pounds of body weight per day, adjusting based on age, activity, and overall health. Always provide fresh water and refrigerate unused portions.

Q4: Does this food help with coat and skin health?
Yes. The combination of omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids from fish and sunflower oil supports a shiny coat, healthy skin, and reduced shedding.

Bottom Line: Should You Buy It?

If you want a premium, grain-free wet food that delivers authentic seafood flavor, wholesome nutrition, and a track record of cat approval, Earthborn Holistic Monterey Medley is well worth the investment. It's ideal as a primary diet or as an indulgent complement to dry kibble.

Give your cat the taste of the ocean—with nutrition you can trust.